How Women Rise at Work and What's Holding You Back
What’s Holding You Back?

How Women Rise at Work and What’s Holding You Back

March 8, 2019

@GettyImages/imagospot

Before you click away – because you’re not a woman, or because you are and you don’t like to be stereotyped – give me a chance to convince you that it’s worth your while reading on.

What's Holding You Back?
Sally Helgesen: “Women in male-dominated fields still encounter skepticism about whether they can do the job.”

Actually, I’ll let Sally Helgesen do it, because these ideas come from her book, “How Women Rise: Break the 12 Habits Holding You Back From Your Next Raise, Promotion, or Job” and I was lucky enough to interview her recently. (You can hear a clip from our full podcast at the foot of this blog.)

“Understanding these behaviors can very much help men to support women, whether as colleagues, mentors or coaches,” Helgesen says.

“I’m also hearing from many men that they identify with some of the behaviors in the book. So, these are not necessarily women’s behaviors, they’re human behaviors. They are the behaviors that we find most likely to get in the way of women as they seek to rise,” she adds.

Stereotyping Women

Helgesen, a women’s leadership expert, says that the gender division is more about experience than biology.

“I do know that men and women often have different experiences, certainly in the workplace. These experiences shape and inform everything, from their confidence level, to how they build relationships, to how they negotiate. These experiences will also shape their expectations,” she says.

“For example, women in male-dominated fields still encounter skepticism about whether they can do the job. This can result in some of the behaviors we describe in this book, such as perfectionism, over-valuing expertise, and putting your job before your career. These come directly as a response to experiences many women have,” Helgesen adds.

Women’s Habits: Fear of Bragging, and the Disease to Please 

Other limiting habits are rooted in how girls and women are expected to behave. These include the first two habits discussed in the book: reluctance to claim your achievements, and expecting others to spontaneously notice and reward your contributions.

Then there’s the huge, familiar challenge of habit eight: the “disease to please.”

In our Expert Interview podcast, Helgesen says that this habit chimes with the themes in her co-author Marshall Goldsmith’s bestseller, “What Got You Here Won’t Get You There.” (You can hear our in-depth review of that book in the Mind Tools Club and Corporate area).

“The motivating desire of the disease to please is really wanting everyone to think you’re a wonderful person, so that you meet their expectations and make life easier for them,” she says. “It can serve you very well earlier in your career, because everybody wants somebody working for them who is trying to please them.

“But, as you assume authority, that investment in the idea that everyone thinks you’re a wonderful person can definitely hold you back. This is because you’re going to have a very difficult time setting boundaries,” she adds.

So, if you want to rise unhindered, “It’s really important to be able to think about letting go of every single person being thrilled at every moment with everything you do, or you are going to really get yourself stuck.”

Women – Claim Your Space!

A couple of the 12 habits are a little more surprising. For instance, number nine is “minimizing” – physically making yourself as small as possible. This can happen when you squeeze up in a crowded meeting, so that latecomers can join the table. Or, worse, when you verbally reduce yourself. How often have you heard yourself say, “This will only take a second”?

“If you’re sending a message to others, ‘I’m not holding my space, I’m not firmly planted,’ then other people [find you] negligible. It’s not a good way of asserting your own presence,” adds Helgesen.

Women’s Words in Leadership

And the opposite of minimizing is just as unhelpful, she continues. This is habit 10, which she calls “too much.” Too much what?

“Too much information, too much disclosure, too much background, too many words,” Helgesen explains, citing research which shows that “women use an average of 20,000 words a day, whereas men use an average of 7,000 words a day.”

This is fine if you’re bonding with a neighbor, or a parent at the school gates. But for women who aspire to be leaders, it’s not a great look.

“In professional situations and cultures where being crisp and concise and authoritative is valued as a leadership style, using too many words and offering too much information is not an effective way of communicating, and certainly not an effective way of positioning yourself as a leader,” Helgesen says.

“How Women Rise” is full of tips and advice on breaking these and other limiting habits. In this clip from our Expert Interview podcast, Helgesen tells us where to start:

 

 

Mind Tools Club and Corporate users can listen to the full 30-minute interview and read a full transcript.

 

Which of Helgesen’s habits ring true for you? Share your experiences and join the discussion below!


6 thoughts on “How Women Rise at Work and What’s Holding You Back

  1. Rebecca Nyafwono wrote:

    This is a good piece of advise to not only me but to my family as a whole. This has been holding us as a family.

    1. Midgie Thompson wrote:

      It is great Rebecca that you can see the connection for other members of your family. That way, everyone can benefit from the ideas discussed.

  2. mbuthia stephen waititu wrote:

    excellence research about what hold women back

    1. Midgie Thompson wrote:

      Thanks for that feedback. Hope you can use some of the ideas presented to help you get ahead.

  3. Helen O wrote:

    I haven’t read the book and will do.. What I find in this snippet “In professional situations and cultures where being crisp and concise and authoritative is valued as a leadership style, using too many words and offering too much information is not an effective way of communicating, and certainly not an effective way of positioning yourself as a leader,” Helgesen says” and the pod snippet is that we are still instructing women in how to adapt themselves to fit into a male dominated culture. Speaking in a more communicative style is not an effective way of positioning yourself as a leader! Yes, remove the superfluous but the preamble and the background often carry the nuances behind the ‘topic’ and can make a significant difference in the outcome (the motivation behind the action and the ethics behind the outcome). Surely, as we move from a competitive to a collaborative world we should be teaching the value and strength in female leadership including a more communicative style of interaction and presentation. Women think speak and act differently because we process, think and act differently and that adds balance, nuance and substance.

    1. Midgie Thompson wrote:

      Thanks Helen for sharing your thoughts. I agree with you that “women think speak and act differently because we process, think and act differently and that adds balance, nuance and substance.” Things are changing, perhaps slowly, yet they are changing. – Midgie, MT

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Please note that we reserve the right to remove comments that we feel are off-topic or offensive. Required fields are marked with an asterisk (*).

View our Privacy Policy.


© Mind Tools Ltd, 1996-2019. All rights reserved. "Mind Tools" is a registered trademark of Mind Tools Ltd.

Click here for permissions information.