What Generation Am I: Geriatric Millennial? » Mind Tools Blog
What Generation Am I?: Geriatric Millennial

What Generation Am I: Geriatric Millennial?

May 28, 2021

Getty Images/SolStock

It’s now possible to find yourself working with people from four different “generations.”

Definitions vary, but there’s a broad consensus based on dates of birth. There are the “Baby Boomers” (born between roughly 1945 and 1964); “Generation X” (1965 to 1980); “Generation Y” or “Millennials” (1980 to 1995); and the newest kids on the workplace block, “Generation Z” (born after 1995).

According to some media reports, this range of different age groups turns the modern workplace into a minefield of misunderstanding, frustration and conflict. But is that really true, or is it just based on the lazy acceptance of unhelpful stereotypes?

What We Think We Know About Generations

We tend to accept and recycle views of the differences between generations without much criticism โ€“ particularly when it reinforces our own prejudices against groups that we don’t belong to.

So, if you’re a Millennial, you may be used to hearing stories about ambitious, self-centered Baby Boomers who don’t much care for feedback.

Or, if you’re a Baby Boomer yourself, you may despair of Generation Xers who aren’t comfortable with authority or strict working hours, and insist on achieving work-life balance over getting the job done.

There may be some broad truth in such generalizations. But there’s also plenty of evidence to suggest that the similarities between generations are more interesting than the differences.

Millennial Myths

Take perceptions of the Millennial cohort (or Generation Y, if you prefer).

There are now more of them in the American workplace than any other age group. Since they were first identified as a group, Millennials have had bad press, particularly from certain sections of the Baby Boomers. The stereotype that developed was of a high-maintenance, even needy, group with questionable loyalty.

Millennials, according to this narrative, jump between jobs at the drop of a hat, need constant reassurance about their performance, and are so wedded to tech and social media that they can barely interact face to face.

Research by IBM paints a different picture, however. In this version of the world, Millennials share many of the same career goals as members of other generations. They prefer their bosses to behave ethically and to share information, rather than to give constant positive feedback.

In learning new skills, they place more value on human interaction than some of their colleagues might expect, given their alleged dependence on the internet. And, compared with Generation X, Millennials will less likely switch jobs for more money, and more likely seek out work that interests them.

Evidence also suggests that attitudes to Millennials among older generations are softening โ€“ or maybe that they were never actually that hard in the first place.

In a survey of 1,000 workers across a broad age range, 82 percent said they would be comfortable reporting to a manager younger than them, while 91 percent said they would be prepared to manage employees older than themselves.

This sounds like a much more relaxed state of affairs than many “generational conflict” stories would have us believe.

What’s a Millennial Anyway?

Part of the problem with the generational debate stems from grouping together people according to arbitrary age ranges. In fact, there are often age-based differences within generational groups that are just as important as those between those groups.

For example, think about the older group of Millennials born in the early 1980s. Recently, digital teamwork expert Erica Dhawan has described them as “Geriatric Millennials.” It sounds kind of unflattering, even though she’s one herself. The term “Xennials” has been around longer, and refers to broadly the same group, emphasizing the characteristics they share with Generation X.

Call them what you will, this cohort will have begun to encounter internet technology as teenagers, but in a relatively primitive form that many of them shaped to their own needs. They include a number of tech innovators, and many of them now lead fast-growing organizations.

Those born 10 to 15 years later will likely have first encountered the online world as younger children. They’ll know about the dotcom bubble of the early 2000s, but it likely didn’t impact their lives in the same way that it did for someone a decade or more older.

The same may be true of events outside the workplace. The 9/11 attacks had a profound effect on everyone who witnessed them, but would the effect they had on a young adult born in 1980 be the same as it was for an eight-year-old? And yet both, by some definitions, are classified as Millennials.

What’s more, the attitudes of any particular group tend to change over time. A Generation Xer born in 1975 probably has a very different set of priorities and concerns in 2021 than they did when entering the workplace in the mid-1990s.

All of this suggests that although it’s worth bearing generational differences in mind, they may not be as divisive as we think.

The Generation After Millennials

For the future, we are already receiving plenty of advice on how to get the best from the latest generation, inevitably tagged “Generation Z.”

Digitally native, entrepreneurial, open-minded, and curious they may well be, but how much of an impact will these characteristics have on how they perform in the workplace? Its too early to tell. It would probably be wise, though, to focus on their behavior and impact as individuals, rather than to make assumptions based on their dates of birth.

Focusing on Similarity

Even if generational differences are less significant than we thought, there are undoubtedly times when they come to the fore. Older workers may find their younger colleagues less receptive to phone calls or face-to-face chats, for example. And younger workers may be frustrated by their elders’ perceived lack of flexibility.

Our article on thriving in a multi-generational workplace offers some useful tips on getting the best from teams made up of a mix of different age groups. But, whatever strategies you use to blend different generations within your team or organization, it’s worth emphasizing what they have in common, rather than what sets them apart.

One piece of research measured generational differences in attitude toward three key workplace “engagement drivers”: future vision, growth and development, and recognition. The results barely differed.

So, if you attend to your individual team members’ goals, give them space to grow as individuals, and recognize their achievements, you may not have to worry so much if they sometimes prefer a text message to a face-to-face meeting.

What experiences, good or bad, have you had of working with people from other generations? Are generational differences a myth or a reality? Do you simply object to such labels on principle? Let us know in the Comments section, below.


9 thoughts on “What Generation Am I: Geriatric Millennial?

  1. Denis W Dubus wrote:

    I’m a late boomer, pun intended, and I’m as comfortable with technology or more than my kids or the employees i lead. Having been on this rock for about 6 decades and traveled extensively, I can attest that the only difference between generations is two things: 1) age and 2) experiences.
    For every argument that can be provided about this or that generation, the counter can also be made. All generations have made significant contributions both positive and negative, and some have been non-descript.
    Humans won’t get over the fact that we’re only special because we say are. We’re unique unto ourselves not because of the year we were accidentally born into.

  2. Cheryl wrote:

    I’m still working, while a lot of my friends have retired from their primary jobs and have either moved on to do something they love, or focus on raising grand children. I am a late bloomer joining the workforce at 35, fulltime after staying home to care for a disable child now an adult. So not working with all age groups, supervised by 30 somethings, leading 20 somethings, and somewhere in the middle are a few 40-50s year olds i also manage. Its been quite an interesting group to listen, manage, teach and learn. I try to keep an open mind when it comes to looking at change and doing something different. I sometimes just need an acknowledgement that my perspective is even value anymore. Wisdom is not always welcomed, being a seasoned manager can be in your favor or go against you. I do think that I bring a perspective to the workplace that is valuable to any discussion but I admit that I must be competent in my knowledge and skills. It helps to surround yourself with the people that you need to do your job even it they are smarter than you.

  3. Jamal Ahmed wrote:

    There should be intergroup discussions about this interesting topic. I have done a humble effort to discuss the “multi generation gap” with my students. The findings were amazing. One is that every generation have their own vocabulary and conceptualization.

  4. Peter McManus wrote:

    When I was in my late twenties my boss, who would become the best person I ever worked for, made the statement that “employees are like children who need to have well-defined parameters.” I took great offense at that statement, but after almost four decades of managing people and becoming the parent of four daughters, I have learned to appreciate the thinking. My point is that often it isn’t so much the generation you were born in with a certain label, but rather the set of experiences you have add compared to others. Hopefully, the older you are the more the experiances. The challenge with my peers from the “older generations” is that we often have higher expectations of younger people than we did of ourselves at the same age.

    1. Yolande Conradie wrote:

      Peter, you hit the nail on the head with this comment:

      we often have higher expectations of younger people than we did of ourselves at the same age

      I often ask myself, “what did I do when I was (x) years old” or “how would I have handled this situation at age (x)”? It helps me to put the behaviour of younger generations in perspective and it also helps me not to label them with negative labels. Diversity is good for any workplace – and age is one of the diversity factors that we shouldn’t overlook.

      Thanks for your comment ๐Ÿ™‚

  5. Geetha Shankar wrote:

    Belonging to Baby Boomer Gen , I have been fortunate working till now with Generation X, , Millennials, Gen Y and Gen Z. I expect all round fairness and productivity in all dimensions of life which I am not able to get from the Generations after mine. Hence have adapted myself to pair up to their needs and contributions so that both parties reap rewards and are in a WIN WIN SCENARIO.

  6. Girija Rao wrote:

    The generations from x to millennials are great at opportunities for anything you name it. Hence these are the people with absolutely positive mind-set and ever flexible in nature. More agile in every aspect are quick at possibilities to know and imagine. That’s the reason why newer versions of technology emerge at less time or shorter intervals of time , with a goal on user-friendly features always. Life for us all became superbly better with conveniences from common to the richest. Happy times ahead๐Ÿ‘

  7. Jake wrote:

    I was born in eighty one, grew up not just around the emergence of tech saw the whole birth of the internet and telecom. Didn’t help that I later found myself in IT, besides the common generational traits mentioned. I would say I had a difficult childhood, which included bullies, private schooling, learning disability and harder to achieve goals than most of my peers growing up. So I don’t exactly fall in the space as some millennials, I don’t take things for granted live and let live I say. I felt the echo of 9/11, I saw the turmoil of centuries economic poverty, I saw the rise/fall of dictators, the failure/change of politics, I’m an Obama/Biden era kid and would vote for either.

    1. Yolande Conradie wrote:

      It’s interesting to hear how other generations view and experience things, so thanks for sharing with us, Jake.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Please note that we reserve the right to remove comments that we feel are off-topic or offensive. Required fields are marked with an asterisk (*).

View our Privacy Policy.