Are You In or Out? » Mind Tools Blog

Are You In or Out?

December 18, 2015

Imagine you’re at work, sitting with your two colleagues. It’s mid-morning and the company coffee bar has opened. One colleague asks, “Fancy a coffee?” You might indeed fancy one, but experience has taught you that the invitation does not extend to you. As usual, the other agrees that a coffee would be a great idea and they rise from their desks and walk off together. I imagine you’d probably feel as I did: a little left out and wondering what it was about me that didn’t quite fit in.

If I was a less confident person, I may have begun to feel that I was at fault. I may even have allowed the situation to affect my performance. However, over time, I could see that their cliquey behavior excluded others too and I realized that their unwillingness to accept me wasn’t really about me… so much as it was about them.

What my colleagues had done was created an in-group… and I was not in it. As Natalie Holder-Winfield explains in her eloquent Expert Interview, in-groups are formed of individuals that have similar characteristics and therefore find it easier to identify and interact with one another. The downside of this can be that they avoid dealing with the out-group, because it can feel less comfortable.

It’s a natural instinct for people to form groups based on their similarities. However, as our article on Managing Mutual Acceptance in Your Team points out, having team members that operate in cliques can put your organization at a disadvantage. Teams that demonstrate unaccepting behaviors can be unstable, unhappy and unproductive. But when people are accepting of diversity, it can lead to better communication and decision making, and therefore better performance by individuals, teams and organizations. And this was borne out by my experience with my two colleagues.

As part of this out-group, I got the distinct feeling that my suggestions and ideas were not particularly welcome. I worked harder to be heard and found ways around their dismissiveness, but this took time and effort that would have been better spent on developing our projects. I despaired at the fact that a little openness from them was all that was needed. On a personal level, I was dismayed that they had made me feel uncomfortable just to avoid their own discomfort but, most of all, I felt sorry for them.

Imagine all the people that you will miss out on knowing, just because you want to avoid the awkwardness of interacting with someone new. We all feel it in varying degrees, the awkwardness of trying to ask the right questions, and the self-consciousness of answering questions about ourselves. But the reward for putting yourself “out there” is that sweet moment when you find the common ground between you, and you begin to feel that you are no longer strangers.

I don’t know about you, but some of the things I’ve done in my life have been inspired by conversations I’ve had with with new people at work. You get to hear about a life that has been lived differently to yours. If you connect well, you can be granted the privilege of finding out the amazing things they’ve done, and this can give you the courage to go for it yourself. After all, if they did it and survived, you’ll probably be OK too. Climb Mount Kilimanjaro, run a marathon, travel abroad by yourself? No problem.

I’d like to say that when it came to the situation with my two colleagues, it all worked out well in the end, and, in a way, it did… for me. I’ve moved on in my career and continue to meet new people and make connections that help me to grow and develop. They, on the other hand, never changed and, as far as I know, are still in the same positions. Since then, I’ve encountered others like them and, where previously I may have withdrawn in the face of their resistance, now I try to remain positive and make inroads with any available opportunity for inclusivity.

If you feel excluded at work but aren’t sure how to address it, or if you feel that you’d like to explore ways to be more inclusive, read our article to find out how. It features a checklist of questions that will help you to identify when behavior is unacceptable, and information on how to support people in speaking up about it.

How about you? Have you ever worked in a place where you felt you didn’t fit in, no matter how you tried? Or can you remember a time when you were able to break through others’ barriers to make a meaningful connection with them? Join in the conversation below!


4 thoughts on “Are You In or Out?

  1. Maris wrote:

    I was more in places where others was ready to accept me, but my mind was protesting for that as in that moment i would betray my values. And result seems logic, that others start make distance.

    As my mission always is outgoing, for me it’s sounds like stupid to make fun (on other side of the doors) about clients, which are new in field and some times have awkward questions or actions. And i don’t speak about “stupid” people. I speak about those, who are going in new with interest, just with out experience jet.

    I am about group who don’t split them selves in n-attitudes.

    As i was a lot digging in my own mind to stop do the same, what done my “teachers” in their lives. After i gone a side from all, for some 6 month first in my life (a lone, no friends, no family, no familiar spot/food etc and amazingly bad internet), now i freely can say, if we talk about such kind of communication in group:

    Support clients in way that support they believe system for
    – i can learn it if i try
    – i can enjoy the process even if i am scared
    – result is outcome from body and mind cooperation in specific environment condition
    – there are many more, what’s can be fitted in that process.

    If i will feel like “not fit in” there, then i will feel bad! All other groups are just random people, from whom always can learn, but they have their own values in which they truly believe.

    About random people/groups – if my understanding is on right way about Physical and Emotional threats have similar chain reactions in HumanAnimals systems, then feeling awkward is just response on some threats. So it’s always good to go where i feel also awkward, that’s helps to find my scares.

  2. Minakshi wrote:

    Yes.. its very common situation. Have faced this multiple times and may i add that apart from feeling hurt and ignored , there is also a sense of insecurity and self pity. We always want to be part of an “IN Group”. But now I have come to realise that there is no such group at work. Its all about convenience. Today we are part of one group and next day of another. This is vicious cycle. What I do now is.. quit trying to be part of a group. Focus on work and if you have great achievements and success.. the “IN Group” would be attracted to you and would like to connect with you. Do share whats your thought about this?

  3. Ikeke wrote:

    Nice article, my challenge is that of having some of my team members in cliques, of which those not in, feels intimidated, and this has visibly affected our outputs as a team, any ideas’ on how this can be successfully handled.

  4. YolandeMT wrote:

    The comments made thus far are very interesting.

    It can have a devastating effect on some people if they suspect they’re being left out.

    Although I know we bond easier with some people than with others and it’s easier to form relationships with some, it’s the decent and courteous thing to do at work to treat everybody with respect and dignity. To me it would simply be unthinkable to offer one person coffee and not another if all three of us share the same office!

    Anybody with personal experience? Please tell us how you handled it or coped with it.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Please note that we reserve the right to remove comments that we feel are off-topic or offensive. Required fields are marked with an asterisk (*).

View our Privacy Policy.


© Mind Tools Ltd, 1996-2019. All rights reserved. "Mind Tools" is a registered trademark of Mind Tools Ltd.

Click here for permissions information.