The Three Component Model of Commitment
Improving Commitment and Engagement
Have you ever thought about why people might become emotionally committed to your organization?
Some people are committed to their jobs because they love what they do, or because their goals align with those of the company. Others might stay because they fear what they could lose if they leave. Still others might stay because they feel obligated to the company, or to their manager.
Clearly, some of these types of commitment can have a negative effect on a person's well-being, self-respect, and job satisfaction. So, how can you avoid this, but still help team members feel committed to your team, or organization, in a positive way?
In this article we'll explore three common types of commitment, and we'll look at how you can make changes to improve team member engagement and loyalty in an effective and positive way.
About the Model
John Meyer and Natalie Allen developed their Three Component Model of Commitment and published it in the 1991 "Human Resource Management Review." The model explains that commitment to an organization is a psychological state, and that it has three distinct components that affect how employees feel about the organization that they work for.
The three components are:
- Affection for your job ("affective commitment").
- Fear of loss ("continuance commitment").
- Sense of obligation to stay ("normative commitment").
You can use this model to increase commitment and engagement in your team, while also helping people to experience a greater feeling of well-being and job satisfaction.
Let's look at each of Meyer and Allen's three types of commitment in greater detail.
Affection for Your Job (Affective Commitment)
Affection for your job occurs when you feel a strong emotional attachment to your organization, and to the work that you do. You'll most likely identify with the organization's goals and values, and you genuinely want to be there.
If you're enjoying your work, you're likely to feel good, and be satisfied with your job. In turn, this increased job satisfaction is likely to add to your feeling of affective commitment.
Fear of Loss (Continuance Commitment)
This type of commitment occurs when you weigh up the pros and cons of leaving your organization. You may feel that you need to stay at your company, because the loss you'd experience by leaving it is greater than the benefit you think you might gain in a new role.
These perceived losses, or "side bets," can be monetary (you'd lose salary and benefits); professional (you might lose seniority or role-related skills that you've spent years acquiring); or social (you'd lose friendships or allies).
The severity of these "losses" often increases with age and experience. You're more likely to experience continuance commitment if you're in an established, successful role, or if you've had several promotions within one organization.
Sense of Obligation to Stay (Normative Commitment)
This type of commitment occurs when you feel a sense of obligation to your organization, even if you're unhappy in your role, or even if you want to pursue better opportunities. You feel that you should stay with your organization, because it's the right thing to do.
This sense of obligation can stem from several factors. You might feel that you should remain with your organization because it has invested money or time in your training. Or perhaps it provided a reward in advance, such as paying for your college tuition.
This obligation can also result from your upbringing. For instance, your family might have stressed that you should stay loyal to your organization.
These three types of commitment are not mutually exclusive. You can experience all three, or two of the three, in varying degrees.
Applying the Model
By applying the Three Component Model, you can help your team develop greater positive, affective commitment. By doing this, your people are likely to feel an increased commitment to the team and organization, and they'll probably feel more positive and more motivated; and experience greater job satisfaction.
It's important to do your best to grow affective commitment, and reduce your team's reliance on continuance and normative commitment, so that you're leading a team of people who feel passionate for their roles.
Team members with only continuance and normative commitment may feel bored and unmotivated, and no leader wants a team with those attitudes! These team members might also block enthusiastic employees, or even lower the morale of the group.
To encourage positive changes, make sure that you're linking people's goals with those of the team or organization, using an approach like Management by Objectives. If appropriate, see whether you can better align your team's roles with their skills and interests, with techniques such as Job Crafting. It's important to help people find purpose in their work.
Remember that people are more likely to develop affective commitment if they experience positive emotions at work. Doing what you can to help people flourish is a great way to encourage people to thrive, and to enjoy the work that they're doing. Make sure that you give praise regularly, and create a healthy workplace, so that people are happy and productive.
Managing Continuance and Normative Commitment
In addition to helping people experience greater affective commitment, you can also use the model to carefully manage the amount of continuance and normative commitment that people may feel.
You can reduce the dependency on continuance and normative commitments by being a better leader, by working on your general team management skills, and by thinking carefully about how your actions might influence your team members.
Clearly, it doesn't make sense to try to reduce continuance or normative commitment, however you should try not to rely on it, even if you're unable to achieve affective commitment at first. You should work on ways to ensure that team members become happy and enjoy their work, without making them feel uncomfortable during the process.
Bear in mind, however, that people will likely experience continuance commitment at some point in their careers, because they'll feel that they need to stay in their job to receive pay and benefits. And some people will likely feel a sense of normative commitment if their organization has invested a lot in their training and development, for example. It's nice to have these types of commitment, however, they're a bonus, not something you should seek to create!
John Meyer and Natalie Allen developed the Three Component Model of Commitment, and published it in the 1991 "Human Resource Management Review." The model defines the three types of commitment as follows:
- Affection for your job (affective commitment).
- Fear of loss (continuance commitment).
- Sense of obligation to stay (normative commitment).
You can use the model to help your people experience greater affective commitment, while making sure that you don't misuse continuance and normative commitment to keep people tied to your team or organization. Your team will function best, and thrive, if you use your energy to grow affective commitment.
This site teaches you the skills you need for a happy and successful career; and this is just one of many tools and resources that you'll find here at Mind Tools. Subscribe to our free newsletter, or join the Mind Tools Club and really supercharge your career!