Emotional Labor

Helping Workers Present a Positive Face

Always presenting a positive face is part of some jobs.

© iStockphoto/gchutka

"Miss, can you bring me a glass of water?"...

"Oh miss, I need some ketchup for my eggs."...

"Oh dear... Miss, my eggs are too runny. I can't possibly eat these. You'll need to send them back, and make sure my order is right this time."...

"Well, now there's a mark on my water glass. Get me a new one!"...

"You expect me to pay full price for this meal? I was served runny eggs and had to go out of my way to ask for water, which was then brought in a dirty glass. I can't believe it. There will certainly be no tip for you, young lady!"

How would you feel if you were the waitress (or waiter) dealing with this customer? Frustrated? Angry? Humiliated? Comments like this from a customer are likely to provoke a negative emotional reaction. However, as a hardworking professional, you would have to hide your personal feelings, and remain calm and positive throughout the exchange.

Does your job require you to manage your emotions, or the way you express those emotions, to meet organizational expectations? This is called 'emotional labor.' People in a service-oriented role – hotel workers, airline flight attendants, tour operators, coaches, counselors – often face the demands of emotional labor.

What is Emotional Labor?

Arlie Hochschild created the term 'emotional labor' in 1983 to describe the things that service workers do that goes beyond physical or mental duties. Showing a genuine concern for customers' needs, smiling, and making positive eye contact are all critical to a customer's perception of service quality. These types of activities, when they're essential to worker performance, are emotional labor.

When you face angry clients, or people who are generally unpleasant, emotional labor can be particularly challenging. A large part of that challenge comes from the need to hide your real emotions, and continue to 'smile and nod your head,' even when receiving negative or critical feedback.

Companies often place a great deal of strategic importance on service orientation, not only to external customers but to colleagues and internal clients as well. While emotional labor is applicable to many areas of business, the consequences are probably greatest in traditional service roles. However, in an increasingly service-oriented marketplace, it's important to understand how emotional labor affects workers, and what organizations can do to support and manage any issues.

Implications for Workers

When you engage in emotional labor, you control your feelings to fulfill the goals and expectations of your organization. From a practical standpoint, this means that you either (a) express only your positive feelings, or (b) hide or manage your negative feelings. To deal with negative emotions, people tend to do one of the following:

  • Show emotion they don't really feel.
  • Hide emotion they really do feel.
  • Create an appropriate emotion for the situation.

You can do this using two emotional labor techniques:

  • Surface acting – You fake, or pretend to have, an emotion by using unnatural and artificial body language and verbal communication. Smiling and using a soft tone of voice help you show emotion that you don't feel, or hide emotion that you do feel.
  • Deep acting – You control your internal emotions, directing them to believe that you actually are happy, and enjoying the interaction with the other person. Rather than feel like you're pretending, you convince yourself you're not experiencing a negative reaction.

When you continually need to show only those emotions that are appropriate for the job, despite how you really feel, this can often lead to emotional conflict between your real emotions and those you show to others.

Some researchers believe that emotional conflict like this leads to emotional exhaustion and burnout for workers – and that hiding your emotions on a regular basis leads to high levels of stress, and even a disconnection from close personal relationships. However, other studies have not found a connection between emotional conflict and emotional exhaustion.

A popular theory to explain this inconsistency in research findings is that individuals vary in their ability to deal with inauthentic, or 'pretend,' emotional expressions. Some workers may be able to identify with the organization's values of positive emotional communication, making them better prepared to express appropriate emotions. Also, people who are generally more cheerful and pleasant may be able to turn off negative emotions more easily than others.

Another factor may be a person's ability to recognize different social situations, and how to behave appropriately. People with more negative personalities and lower social awareness tend to have the hardest time dealing with emotional conflict – and they probably experience emotional exhaustion more easily.

To get a better understanding of emotional labor, here are some questions to ask yourself and, perhaps, to explore with your team:

  • What are the emotional labor requirements of your job?
  • How do you deal with these requirements?
  • How often do you experience emotional conflict?
  • Do you think emotional conflict has led to emotional exhaustion?
  • How do you manage stress and other signs of emotional exhaustion?

By regularly examining the role of emotional labor in your work, you can help reduce the potential negative effects – and continue to provide high-quality service to internal and external customers.

Implications for Organizations

It's important for workers to understand the impact that emotional labor has on their performance. However, it's essential that organizations are also aware of this requirement, so they can find ways to provide support to their workers, and help them deal with the impact of emotional labor.

Service workers typically need to perform in a certain manner if they're going to provide high quality service. This is usually defined by management, then strictly regulated and monitored. For example, customer service rules might be 'The customer is always right,' or 'Always greet customers with a smile.'

Expecting people to work in teams, and show positive team behaviors with their colleagues, adds another element of emotional labor. In fact, many organizations place a growing emphasis on building relationships with a wide variety of stakeholders. This comes with many emotional labor conditions.

It's reasonable to believe that helping people deal with the consequences of emotional labor will improve staff morale and reduce staff turnover. Here are some common strategies that organizations use to help their staff deal with the demands of emotional labor:

  • Use buffering – Companies may assign front-end personnel to manage the emotional demands and needs of customers. By the time customers reach back-end workers, they can concentrate on business.
  • Teach 'display' rules – These are organizationally approved norms or standards that workers learn through observation, instruction, feedback, and reinforcement. Staff are taught how to act, and they may even be given scripts to use when dealing directly with clients. Therapists are taught to act neutrally, retail workers are taught to act positively, and bill collectors are often taught to act aggressive. Combining these display rules with company culture is very important.
  • Offer staff assistance programs – Organizations invest in the care and development of their workers by providing access to stress management and emotional health services. This strategy recognizes that emotional labor can be hard work.
  • Teach problem-solving techniques – To move workers beyond using scripts or relying on other display rules, some companies help their staff solve problems more effectively. This helps people build confidence, and reduce their negative reactions to angry or unpredictable situations. The better that workers are able to deal with problems, the more likely they are to resolve interpersonal issues before they lead to negative emotions.
  • Improve emotional intelligence – The ability to recognize other people's emotions is an effective way to reduce the burden of emotional labor. Building empathy   and using other emotional intelligence   tools help reduce the likelihood that emotional conflict will lead to emotional exhaustion.
  • Share knowledge – One of the most effective ways to help people deal with the realities of emotional labor is to share success stories. Allow staff to learn how others successfully deal with the impact of emotional conflict.
  • Bring emotional labor into the performance evaluation process – Organizations can recognize the importance of emotional labor by measuring workers' emotional effort factors and commitment to customer service. How well do workers deal with angry people? What type of attitude do they bring to work every day? Do they show tolerance and patience? When workers are rewarded for their emotional labor, it provides an incentive for them to show organizationally accepted emotions more often.

Used appropriately, these strategies can take much of the pain out of emotional labor. Indeed, where problems are addressed appropriately, service workers often report tremendous levels of satisfaction when they're able to help clients resolve their problems.

Many people would say that it's important to be authentic in all your communications. Clearly, this conflicts with the organization's need for customer service personnel to leave customers feeling positive and happy about their experience. The approaches described above are also useful for helping individuals reconcile these conflicting requirements.

Key Points

Emotional labor occurs when workers are paid, in part, to manage and control their emotions. Traditionally, we've seen this in service-oriented professions. But service excellence is now a key driver of success in most organizations, so elements of emotional labor are present in almost all workplaces. It's important to understand the impact of emotional labor, and how it affects workers.

Emotions at work are an important part of company life. Help people understand their reactions to emotional labor, and develop policies and procedures to reduce the negative impact of emotional labor. These are ways to improve overall performance and worker satisfaction.

This site teaches you the skills you need for a happy and successful career; and this is just one of many tools and resources that you'll find here at Mind Tools. Click here for more, subscribe to our free newsletter, or become a member for just $1.

Add this article to My Learning Plan

Comments (13)
  • Yolande wrote Over a month ago
    HI Amishyasiri

    A warm welcome to the Club and to the forums as well. It's great to hear that the article gave you some new insights. If you have any questions or ideas that you'd like to share with us or that you'd like input on, please feel free to post on one of the forums such as Career Cafe Central - that is where we all help and learn from one another.

    Just on breathing: recently I attended a workshop where one of the techniques we were taught, was to imagine your breath coming through your feet and you have to pull it all the way up to the lungs. It really makes you breathe quite deeply and of course, also a bit slower. It has a very calming effect and has helped me to focus on what's important in the moment.

    Amishyasiri, if you need any help around here, please don't hesitate to let me know. We look 'forward' to seeing you around!

    Kind regards
    Yolandé
  • Amishyasiri wrote Over a month ago
    Hello All,
    I am new to mind tools club, I am current pursuing my masters studies with a university in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. One of my first assignment under OB is Emotional Labour. After having read the suggested articles and your respective comments, I now have better insights to start penning down my assignments.

    Looking forward to more chats soon. P/s I think I am quick to respond be it positive or negative...this at times does not go well at both personal and professionally. Yes, perhaps the right breathing technique might help,

    Cheers
    Amishyasiri Suresh
  • Midgie wrote Over a month ago
    Thanks Aeonima for the suggestion about focusing on your breath.

    Our breathing does indeed change when our emotions change. When we get stressed, upset or even angry, we cut our breath short and shallow.

    So, by focusing on your breath, you remind yourself to take deep, regular, breaths and this helps to calm down the entire body.

    Have others tried the 'focusing on your breath' strategy and how did it work for you?
    Midgie
  • aeonima wrote Over a month ago
    Enjoy your breath

    It means: anytime I get too emotional I focus on my breath, in through the nose, out through the mouth (but not like a steam engine)...

    Helps me to stay cool...

    Cheers, Aeonima
  • MichaelP wrote Over a month ago
    Hi, the 4 key body language things that to me show you are in control even if frustrated and yet not threatening are.

    Eye contact,
    a smile ( at least not a scowl) you can acknowledge the person with a smile even if you disagree with their points. Agree to disagree.
    Minimal movement. (hands Body Head)
    Silence. (never open you mouth unless you are sure what you are going to say is better than silence!)

    what do other suggest?

    cheers Michael
  • alleeh wrote Over a month ago
    I'm like Franny - taught that feeling emotions was ok. I have trouble putting on a poker face. If I'm frustrated - it shows. I never saw this as a problem, but recent events at work have proven that I need to change this aspect of my character. I like the idea of being more "diplomatic". What are some other tools to "hide the emotions" without emotional overload? How can I improve my body language so that my frustration isn't perceived as defensive or confrontational?
  • Midgie wrote Over a month ago
    Thanks Cos for sharing how you deal with your boss that you do not like. The very specific ways you interact with them can help others think of ways they can interact with people they do not particularly like!

    Call it diplomacy, tact, playing the game ... whatever it takes to help you get along in your organisation! Yet there is a balance between being diplomatic and not expressing your thought about someone or something in a blunt manner, and being assertive and ensuring your boundaries are respected.

    Midgie
  • cobberas wrote Over a month ago
    I'm like you Franny - I also didn't know there was a term for it, but I'm in a workplace (rather than a career) that relies on it!

    I've seen some exceptionally talented workers here get put through the mill and then terminated despite their high quality and quantity outputs, because they didn't 'play the game'. Likewise I've seen one individual who loafed for a full 12m at work - sitting on chat rooms with the boss fully aware of it (some of you might remember my frustrations around this situation), then get awarded a 4-year scholarship for postgraduate study, because 'the boss likes her'.

    I don't like my boss. I don't like the way he operates. But when I come in to work in the morning, I plaster a big smile on my face and greet him with a cheerful voice, I laugh at his jokes, I 'oooh' and 'ahhh' at him about his accomplishments - like everyone else does around here - and we get along just fine. Before I started doing this, he snapped and grouched at me continually, no matter how hard I worked.

    Is this being two-faced of me? I see it as diplomacy! And the fact that the boss doesn't see through my antics just makes my task a whole lot easier!!

    Cheers
    Cos
  • Dianna wrote Over a month ago
    Hi Franny,

    What I think you are describing is difficulty being assertive. It's a hard line to walk sometimes and the best way to improve is to practice. Here is the article we have on assertiveness: http://mindtools.com/community/pages/ar ... veness.php And one on managing your boundaries: http://mindtools.com/community/pages/ar ... TCS_87.php

    As well we have a Bite Sized Training on the topic that has practical exercises to complete: http://www.mindtools.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=1207

    As you get more comfortable identifying and describing what you need in a situation it is easier to communicate those needs while remaining calm, composed, and professional. It's more than expressing your feelings - which is very important - assertiveness helps you do it in a way that respects the other person and his/her perspective as well. In the end both parties feel respected, heard, and understood and that's the foundation of good communication whether it's with peers, bosses, customers, associates, friends, or family.

    Best wishes! Let us know how things go for you.

    Dianna
  • franny wrote Over a month ago
    I like the advice that you gave, Midgie. Fortunately for me, I have not been labelled as unprofessional before but it sometimes feels like I could snap and end that.

    I tend to be too passive in work situations to compensate for how I really want to react. However that just leaves me feeling angry with myself for being such a doormat. I often do not confront people at work when they overstep my boundaries. It's as if I get tongue tied. What could I do in these situations? As a manager, I am aware that I need to be able to speak my truth and remain professional. This makes me feel emotionally drained at times but at least I can now see why.
Show all comments

Where to go from here:

Join the Mind Tools Club

Click to join Mind Tools
Printer-friendly version
Return to the top of the page

Create a Login to Save Your Learning Plan

This ensures that you don’t lose your plan.


Connect with…

Or create a Mind Tools login. Existing user? Log in here.
Log in with your existing Mind Tools details
Lost Username or Password
You are now logged in…

Lost username or password?

Please enter your username or email address and we'll send you a reminder.

Thank You!

Your log in details have been sent to the email account you registered with. Please check your email to reset your login details.

Create a Mind Tools Login
Your plan has been created.

While you're here, subscribe to our FREE newsletter?

Learn a new career skill every week, and get our Personal Development Plan workbook (worth $19.99) when you subscribe.


Thank You!

Please check your Inbox, and click on the link in the email from us. We can then send you the newsletter.